PayStubVerifier

How to spot fake pay stubs

Last updated September 30, 2026

To spot a fake pay stub, check the arithmetic: gross minus deductions should equal net, earnings lines should add up to gross, and year-to-date totals should grow by exactly one period's pay from stub to stub. Then confirm with an independent source such as bank deposits or the employer.

Online pay stub generators make a convincing-looking stub in minutes, and editing a real PDF is easier still. What they rarely get right is the arithmetic that ties a genuine stub together, and the way a series of stubs agrees with itself. These checks start with the math, which is the hardest part to fake.

Checks on a single stub

1. Gross minus deductions equals net. Add up every tax and deduction for the current period and subtract it from gross pay. The result should match net pay to the cent. Someone who raises the gross to look better often forgets to change the net, or changes the net and not the deductions.

2. The earnings lines add up to gross. Regular pay, overtime, bonus and other lines should sum to the gross shown. Hours times rate should match each line's amount.

3. Year-to-date is at least the current period. A year-to-date gross smaller than this period's pay is impossible on a real stub.

4. Payroll taxes are about the right size. Social Security is 6.2% of wages up to the annual wage base and Medicare is 1.45%, so together they should come to about 7.65% of taxable gross. Pre-tax deductions such as 401(k) contributions and health premiums lower the taxable amount, so the figures won't always be exact, but a stub with no Social Security or Medicare at all, or wildly different amounts, needs an explanation.

5. The dates make sense. The pay date should fall shortly after the period ends, usually within a week or two, and the period length should match the pay frequency: seven days for weekly, fourteen for biweekly.

Checks across several stubs

Ask for consecutive stubs, usually the last two or three. A series is much harder to fake than one page.

6. Year-to-date grows by exactly one period's pay. From one stub to the next, the year-to-date gross should increase by the new stub's current gross. Fabricated stubs made one at a time almost never line up.

7. No gaps or overlaps. Each pay period should start the day after the last one ended. A missing week or an overlapping period suggests stubs from different sources.

8. The same employer, formatted the same way. Employer name, address, employee ID and layout should stay consistent across stubs from one job.

Checks outside the stub

9. Confirm with an independent source. Match deposits on a bank statement to the net pay on the stubs. Call the employer using a phone number you looked up yourself, not the one printed on the stub. For loans, W-2s, tax transcripts and a verification of employment settle the question.

A failed check is a question, not a verdict

Real stubs fail checks too. Payroll corrections, retroactive raises, a mid-year change of payroll provider and one-off adjustments all produce numbers that look wrong. When something doesn't add up, ask the applicant about it and look for independent confirmation before drawing a conclusion. Apply the same checks to every applicant.

Let software do the arithmetic

PayStubVerifier runs the arithmetic checks above on every stub you upload: gross against net, earnings lines against gross, year-to-date against the current period, and, across stubs, year-to-date growth, gaps, overlaps and a change of employer name. Each flag names the stub and the numbers involved. It also works out annual and monthly income and the rent-to-income ratio. Hours times rate, tax amounts, dates, layout consistency and independent confirmation are still yours to check.

One page a day is free, no account needed. Upload a stub to try it, or read how it works for landlords and lenders.